Rent vs Buy Calculator
Is it better to rent or buy?
There is a lot of uncertainty about whether you should rent or buy your home. Our rent vs buy calculator compares the two over time, based on the figures you enter.
It charts 'Rent - Savings' against 'Buy - Home Equity' year by year and shows which comes out ahead at the end of the period you choose, and by how much.
How to use the rent vs buy calculator
Fill in the three groups of figures:
- Financial position — how much you have saved, the return your savings or investments earn, and the time period to compare.
- Rent details — your rent and how often you pay it, and how much it rises each year.
- Buy details — the purchase price, upfront purchase costs, ongoing costs and how much they rise each year, home appreciation, and the loan amount, term, interest rate and monthly repayment.
The calculator starts with example figures, including a 5.5% loan rate and 3% a year home appreciation. Replace them with your own: they are illustrative, not a forecast or a rate offered by Greenline Home Loans or any lender.
What the rent or buy calculator assumes
- Results are in future dollars and not adjusted for inflation. To allow for inflation, lower the savings and investment return and the home appreciation.
- It doesn't take into account the tax implications of buying or renting, or tax on your savings and investment returns.
- Savings returns, rent increases, ongoing cost increases and home appreciation are calculated yearly, so they compound yearly.
- The home loan repayments include principal and interest, calculated monthly.
Rent vs buy: the costs of buying
Upfront purchase costs are the one-off costs of buying, such as stamp duty, moving expenses and legal fees. Our property buying cost calculator estimates the total cost of buying a home, and our stamp duty calculator estimates the duty.
Ongoing costs are what you pay each year to own the home, such as council rates, insurance and maintenance.
To check what you could borrow, use our borrowing power calculator, and to estimate your repayments, our loan repayment calculator.
Renting or buying: what tips the balance
The calculator does the arithmetic; these are the inputs that usually decide the result, so they are worth entering carefully rather than leaving at the defaults.
- How long you stay: the one-off costs of buying, such as stamp duty and legal fees, are spread over the years you own the home, so a short stay favours renting and a long one favours buying.
- Your deposit: a deposit of 20% or more avoids lenders mortgage insurance and usually earns a lower rate, which changes the cost of buying from the first year. Our deposit calculator shows how much to put away each month to get there.
- The gap between rent and a repayment: where rents are high relative to prices, buying catches up sooner; where they are low, the money you keep by renting has to be saved or invested to keep pace.
- The growth and return assumptions: home appreciation and the return on savings are forecasts, not facts, so try a lower and a higher figure and see whether the answer holds.
Renting where you want to live while buying an investment property elsewhere, sometimes called rentvesting, is a third option the calculator does not model. A Greenline broker can run the numbers on it with you.
Rent vs buy calculator FAQs
Is it better to rent or buy?
It depends on your own numbers: the property price, your rent, how much you have saved, the loan rate, and how fast rents, costs and home values grow. The rent vs buy calculator compares the two on your figures over the period you choose.
What does 'Buy - Home Equity' mean?
Home equity is the value of the home less what you still owe on the loan. The calculator projects it from the purchase price, the home appreciation and the loan details you enter.
Does the calculator allow for inflation?
No. Results are in future dollars. To allow for inflation, lower the savings and investment return and the home appreciation.
Does it include tax?
No. It doesn't take into account the tax implications of buying or renting a property, or tax on savings or investment returns.
What should I include in upfront purchase costs?
The one-off costs of buying, such as stamp duty, moving expenses and legal fees. Our property buying cost calculator can estimate them.
Is the result a recommendation?
No. It is an estimate based on your inputs and the calculator's assumptions, not advice. Speak to a Greenline broker about your situation.
How long should I plan to stay for buying to make sense?
There is no fixed number: the longer you own the home, the more years the upfront costs of buying are spread across, and the calculator shows the year the buy line overtakes the rent line for your own figures. Enter a shorter and a longer period and compare the two results.
What growth rate should I use for the home?
The calculator starts at 3% a year, which is an illustration, not a forecast. Nobody knows future prices, so test a range, for example a lower and a higher figure, and see whether the result changes. If the answer only works with strong growth, that is worth knowing.
Does renting and investing elsewhere change the answer?
It can. Renting where you want to live and buying an investment property elsewhere, often called rentvesting, mixes the two columns the calculator compares and adds rental income and tax to the picture, so it is not modelled here. Speak to a Greenline broker if you are weighing it up.
The information here is general in nature, does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and does not constitute credit assistance, financial advice or an offer of credit.
Apply for a Loan Today!
Get started on your loan journey with Greenline Home Loans. We’re here to help! Speak to one of our professional lenders today.
